Who Pays Medical Malpractice Claims?

Key Takeaways

• Medical malpractice insurance pays covered malpractice claims, not healthcare professionals.
• Insurers investigate claims thoroughly before paying.
• Without adequate coverage, providers are at risk of paying out of pocket.

---

If you’re a healthcare professional, the thought of facing a malpractice claim might keep you up at night. But this might help you get back to sleep: medical malpractice insurance protects you from personal financial devastation if you do have a claim made against you, even one that is later proved baseless. So if you’re wondering who pays medical malpractice claims, you can rest assured that in most cases, you won’t be paying out of pocket.

In this article, we explain who actually pays medical malpractice claims — and go over the circumstances that could trigger your liability. We also discuss how the payment process works, what role your medical malpractice insurance plays, and when you might need additional coverage to stay protected.

Who Actually Pays Medical Malpractice Claims?

As you probably know, the way insurance works is that you, the customer, pay regular monthly or annual premiums to maintain your medical malpractice insurance coverage. In exchange, the insurance company assumes the financial risk of defending you against covered claims and paying out settlements or judgments up to your policy limits. This arrangement protects you from the potentially catastrophic financial impact of a malpractice lawsuit. Payments can range from thousands to hundreds of thousands (or even millions) of dollars.

Your insurance carrier covers several key expenses when a claim is filed:

• Your legal defense, including:
  • Attorneys’ fees
  • Expert witnesses
  • Court costs
  • All other litigation expenses
• Settlements or judicial awards. This means that if both parties agree to settle for a certain financial payment, or the case goes to trial and results in a judgment against you, the insurance company pays the settlement or award amount up to your policy limits.

This protection is why medical malpractice insurance exists — to shield healthcare professionals from personal financial disaster while ensuring that injured patients receive appropriate compensation.

How Insurance Companies Decide Whether to Pay or Defend a Claim

When your insurance company receives a claim, it doesn’t immediately write a check or book a court date. Usually an experienced claims examiner is assigned to help you. They conduct a thorough evaluation to determine the best course of action. Understanding this process can help you know what to expect if you ever face a claim. Below is how Berxi typically handles a claim.

Step 1: The claims examiner contacts you

Your claim first is assigned to a specific claims team member who will reach out, usually via email or phone. They will want to hear your story and will ask you questions about your patient notes, relevant files, and other providers involved.

Step 2: The claims examiner hears the other side

Often the claims examiner will also contact the claimant’s attorney (aka the person who accused you) to hear their side of the story.

Step 3: An attorney is often assigned

Once it’s determined that your policy covers the claim, the claims examiner often will assign your case to one of the insurance company’s vetted and experienced attorneys, one judged to be the best fit for your situation.

Step 4: Experts evaluate your liability

Depending on how severe or complicated the allegations, various experts might be consulted to determine some of the following:

• Clinical liability: Insurance claims examiners and medical experts review the medical records, treatment protocols, and standard of care to determine whether the circumstances meet the criteria for malpractice.
• Plaintiff’s case: This team also examines whether a breach of the standard of care occurred and whether that breach caused harm.

Step 5: Your team decides on defense strategy

If your legal team determines that the opposing side has strong enough evidence to prove that negligence or malpractice may have taken place, negotiations will start. This can start with mediation and might end with a trial or settlement. At Berxi, your claims examiner is in charge of keeping you in the loop every step of the way.

Additional Medical Malpractice Claim Considerations

Who pays a claim can get more complicated in certain situations. Let’s explore some important exceptions and special circumstances you should know about.

1. Uninsured & underinsured healthcare providers

Some states don’t require healthcare professionals to carry malpractice insurance, leading some providers to practice without coverage (sometimes referred to as “going bare”) or with limits too low to offer real protection.

If a claim is filed and you’re uninsured or underinsured, you can be held personally responsible for the full settlement or judgment. Your home, savings, investments, and even future earnings can be targeted through liens or garnishments.

Skipping adequate coverage may save you money in the short term, but it can expose you to catastrophic financial risk.

2. State patient compensation funds

Some states operate patient compensation funds that provide extra coverage when malpractice claims exceed a provider’s insurance limits. If a judgment surpasses your policy — for instance, a $2 million award on a $1 million policy — the state patient compensation fund may help cover the difference.

Participation usually requires providers to pay surcharges or assessments, and payouts are often capped. These programs vary widely, and not all states offer them, so it’s important to understand your state’s rules and whether enrollment is automatic or optional.

3. Multiple defendants & shared liability

Malpractice claims often involve multiple defendants because patient care typically includes many professionals and organizations. A single case may name physicians, specialists, nurses, physical therapists, facilities, or even corporations providing hospital services, such as laboratories or dialysis centers.

What Happens If a Claim Exceeds My Medical Malpractice Insurance Coverage?

If a malpractice claim is higher than your policy limits, you may be personally responsible for the amount above your coverage. For example, if your limit is $1 million but a case settles for $1.5 million, your insurance pays $1 million and you owe the remaining $500,000.

This is why choosing adequate limits of liability matters. Higher limits increase your premium, but they also protect you from rare but potentially devastating claims. When deciding your limits, consider:

• Your role and scope of practice
• Whether you work in a high‑risk setting
• Typical claim amounts and jury awards in your state

Healthcare professionals in higher‑risk roles or settings — such as emergency care, obstetrics, or advanced practice — may benefit from higher coverage.

Is Employer-Provided Medical Malpractice Insurance Enough to Protect You?

Many healthcare professionals rely exclusively on employer-provided medical malpractice insurance, assuming they’re fully protected. Unfortunately, there are a number of ways employer coverage can fall short.

1. Job changes

If your employer provides claims-made coverage (the most common type), you’re covered only for claims filed while you’re employed there and the policy is active. If a patient files a claim after you leave, you may not be covered unless you purchase “tail coverage.”

2. Employer policies may have lower limits than you need

This can especially be true if you’re in a high-risk specialty.

3. Employer policies don’t usually cover licensing board reviews

Board reviews can happen out of the blue. And complaints, even when later proven baseless, can cause stress, lost work time, and potential reputational harm. One employer, for example, accused an RN of being drunk at work and, despite her testing negative, still submitted the incident to the licensing board. Another doctor, annoyed that NPs in his state were allowed full practice authority, submitted a complaint to the licensing board and named an NP entrepreneur with her own practice.

Both stories involve healthcare professionals who were not negligent in any way but were forced to deal with the board complaint process nevertheless.

4. There’s a conflict of interest

If your interest in the case is at odds with the employer’s interest, you’ll want your own defense counsel.

For example, let’s say several providers who saw a patient are named in a claim, including you. This healthcare team is being represented by the employer’s medical malpractice policy. However, your patient notes differ from those of a doctor who saw the patient on the same day. In fact, you can’t back the doctor up and think something is fishy. You’re going to want your own defense counsel.

5. Provider works “outside the scope”

Coverage disputes can arise when your employer’s insurer argues that certain actions fell outside your scope of employment, leaving you without coverage.

For example, a physical therapist attends a running club’s social event and gives a stretching overview as a representative of the PT practice. Someone pulls a muscle during their stretch and blames the PT and submits a claim naming the practice where the PT works. This could be considered out of the scope of practice and not covered by the employer’s policy.

6. Provider has a side hustle

If you do any moonlighting, consulting, or side work, your employer’s policy likely won’t cover those activities.

7. Bad coverage

Sometimes your employer just didn’t go with a great insurance company, and they drop the ball. In fact, this is a real story of an NP’s employer-provided insurance failing her.

Supplemental or individual medical malpractice insurance can help fill these gaps by providing continuous protection regardless of where you work. Individual policies travel with you from job to job, cover your professional activities outside your primary employment, and give you control over your coverage limits and policy terms.

Protect Your Career With Berxi Medical Malpractice Insurance

You’ve worked too hard to build your career to leave it vulnerable to a single malpractice claim. Berxi makes it simple to get the protection you need with affordable, comprehensive medical malpractice insurance backed by the A++ financial strength of Berkshire Hathaway Specialty Insurance Company.

Berxi’s direct-to-customer approach cuts out broker fees and unnecessary costs, saving you an average of 20%. Get an instant quote, purchase coverage, manage your policy, generate certificates of insurance, and file claims entirely online — all while having access to Berxi’s world-class, in-house customer support.

Get a quote for medical malpractice insurance today.

Medical Malpractice Claims FAQ

Do healthcare providers pay malpractice settlements out of their own pockets?

In most cases, no. Medical malpractice insurance pays settlements and judgments on behalf of insured healthcare providers. However, if you’re uninsured or underinsured, face a claim that exceeds your policy limits, or face a claim that is not covered by your insurance, you may become personally responsible.

Does my employer’s malpractice insurance cover me after I leave my job?

It depends on the type of policy. If your employer provides occurrence coverage, you’re covered for incidents that occurred during your employment, even if the claim is filed after you leave. However, most employer policies are claims-made, which means you’re covered only for claims filed while you’re employed and the policy is active. You may need to purchase tail coverage to maintain protection after leaving.

Who decides whether to settle a malpractice claim or go to trial?

Typically the policy holder and their legal team decide whether they settle or go to trial. However, the legal team and claims examiner will likely have a strong opinion, since they will have heard the evidence from both sides of the claim. If you don’t want to settle, and your policy includes a “consent to settle” clause, you will have more control in the decision.

Can I be sued personally even if I have malpractice insurance?

Yes, you can still be named in a lawsuit even with insurance. However, this is what malpractice insurance is for. You’re personally at risk only for amounts that exceed your coverage limits or for claims that fall outside your policy’s scope of coverage.

 

Image courtesy of iStock.com/AndreyPopov

Image courtesy of iStock.com/WhiteTea

Image courtesy of iStock.com/PeopleImages

Image courtesy of iStock.com/fizkes

Image courtesy of iStock.com/DragonImages

More:

• Mental Health
• Fitness & Wellness
• Optometrists
• Nurse
• Insurance EDU
• PT
• OT
• PA
• NP
• Optometrist
• RN

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Berxi™ or Berkshire Hathaway Specialty Insurance Company. This article (subject to change without notice) is for informational purposes only, and does not constitute professional advice. Click here to read our full disclaimer